Puppy Forum and Dog Forums banner

**CONTROVERSIAL QUESTION** raw feeders

2 reading
2.1K views 21 replies 8 participants last post by  ioreks_mom  
#1 ·
please don't attack me for this. i know that a lot of animals are hunted and unfortunately these animals were hunted in a violent way for a long time. i don't think it is like that any more.

i was wondering if it is ok to feed seal meat to iorek? i would freeze it for a month first. it will be very easy and very cheap for me to get seal meat once the hunt starts here (i live in Newfoundland). the owner of the raw food company i used to buy from in nova scotia said that seal meat is good for dogs but he never carried it since it is so controversial. he said that he has fed it to his dogs but not the bones. i just thought i would ask here because it will be so easy for me to get in the winter. is seal meat and bones ok to feed to iorek?

i really don't want this to start a discussion on whether or not the seal hunt is ok. thank you in advance for that.
 
#4 · (Edited)
thank you. right now calories are not a concern for us. iorek needs to put weight on. do you think that if i feed him a lb of seal instead of 1 1/2 lbs that should work out ok?

also, do you think the bones should be ok? i am guessing that as long as they are not too thick they should be fine? i guess there are not too many weight bearing bones in an animal who lives in the ocean.
 
#5 ·
I have to disagree. Meat is not MEAT! Seriously, when Iorek is lounging around doesn't he already look like a baby seal? Do you really want Iorek looking at you as if to suggest Soylent Green(seal meat) is doggy! So ya, meat is not just meat. :p
 
#10 · (Edited)
Yes arctic wolves eat seals.


See, now I believe it's not actually the seal that has a lot of fat, it's the blubber, or a layer of fat, which keeps the seals warm. If you get their fat, then it's pure fat, but if you get the meat, I think it's just meat..
 
#12 ·
I don't believe this is the case. All aquatic mammals have extremely oily meat. It's like when you fry a steak, it can be really fatty or it can be really meaty, and that determines the grease you get out of it. If you fried seal meat (or any aquatic mammal for that matter), it would liberate a TON of grease.
 
#17 ·
That's not entirely true. Sled dogs eat seal (and in my part of the country beaver) because it is so incredibly high in fat and therefore calories. They also run 50-100 miles a day. They also switch into pure fat liberation metabolism after the first 100 or so miles of a race. Your housepet doesn't get nearly that exercise. My concern is that they would be getting plenty of calories, but not enough other nutrients.

Will it kill your dog, absolutely not. On a normal feed amount will they have all the nutrients they need? I'm not sure.

I'd have it just added into your normal protein rotation, not something you feed every day.
 
#21 ·
Haha, me too! Plenty of fat on a pet rabbit, though.....my girls look like furry basketballs, LOL. I probably should cut back on their pellets.