Puppy Forum and Dog Forums banner

How do I teach a dog "quiet" when he doesn't bark at treats?

38 views 1 reply 2 participants last post by  DoggyWoodsDogTV  
#1 ·
I tried researching how to train a dog to stop barking on command, but all the online guides are like "Okay, so first, hold up a treat, then wait for your dog to bark, then say 'quiet'." But the thing about Toby's barking problem is, it just doesn't apply to food! He's such a gentleman when he's begging.

Of course I'm thankful for this (he begs for food A LOT, so it would be an absolute nightmare if he barked about it), but it also means those training guides don't apply to him. What he DOES bark at is basically any person or dog making themselves known anywhere near our property. For example, our next door neighbors have a dog, and when it barks, Toby barks even more than that dog does. And when anyone in our neighborhood is making any kind of noise, whether it's some kind of machinery or literally just talking in their backyard, Toby won't shut up about that, either.

And if someone is called to our house or yard to do some work, Toby goes BANANAS.

But again, when it comes to food, all that goes out the window and leaves behind a perfect little gentleman.

So, how do I teach him the "quiet" command if he barks at everything but food?
 
#2 ·
When it comes to barking, food can actually backfire. A lot of guides say “get them to bark, then reward,” but that’s teaching the exact opposite of what you want — you’re rewarding the act of barking, not the quiet that follows.

What works better is setting a very clear boundary. The moment your dog reacts to a noise, you calmly but firmly interrupt it — whether that’s a sound you make, a quick step into their space, or even just a strong body signal that says, “no, not now.” You’re marking the line in the sand. Then, just as important, you wait. Don’t reward or soothe during the barking. Only when your dog gives you that moment of calm — ears relaxed, body softer, mouth closed — that’s when you mark it positively with praise, affection, or a treat.

It’s less about distracting with food, and more about communicating: “this behavior isn’t what I want, but this calm state is.” Dogs learn a lot faster when the timing is clear. Be consistent, and soon “quiet” becomes a state they default to, instead of something you’re begging them for with a treat in hand.