Your father isn't wrong in itself...plenty of people do play with their dogs that way, but for this particular dog, yes, I do think he needs to adjust his behavior. She is displaying stress signals, which he is ignoring. You didn't mention how long you have had her. It may be that she is still adjusting to your home, too, and it will take some time for her to come out of her shell.
Interacting with her using toys is fine. Some dogs don't really know what toys are, and that they're for playing. You might suggest to your dad that he try teaching the dog the "Find It" game. So hide her toys, and every time she finds one she gets a treat. Dogs aren't going to get that they're supposed to go and find the toys just because you hide them, but if you teach her what she is supposed to do she might find it enjoyable.
You could also teach your dad to teach the dog these games. Putting toys back in a bucket, putting her feet in a box. Look up 100 things to do with a box. Your dad just seems to want to play with her, so we're going to treat him a bit like a dog and instead of telling him what he's doing is wrong, we're going to redirect to an alternate behavior, haha. Hopefully, he'll see the difference between a happy dog who enjoys the activity rather than a dog who is confused but tolerating it.
And, maybe, as she gains more confidence she will enjoy the games he likes, too.
Interacting with her using toys is fine. Some dogs don't really know what toys are, and that they're for playing. You might suggest to your dad that he try teaching the dog the "Find It" game. So hide her toys, and every time she finds one she gets a treat. Dogs aren't going to get that they're supposed to go and find the toys just because you hide them, but if you teach her what she is supposed to do she might find it enjoyable.
You could also teach your dad to teach the dog these games. Putting toys back in a bucket, putting her feet in a box. Look up 100 things to do with a box. Your dad just seems to want to play with her, so we're going to treat him a bit like a dog and instead of telling him what he's doing is wrong, we're going to redirect to an alternate behavior, haha. Hopefully, he'll see the difference between a happy dog who enjoys the activity rather than a dog who is confused but tolerating it.
And, maybe, as she gains more confidence she will enjoy the games he likes, too.