I was feeding Odin 2 cups a day of Nature's Variety Instinct. He was pooping 4-5 times a day. Even though they were solid that was an increase over his crappy food (Purina One). It was suggested that I was feeding him too much and to cut back. I decreased it to a cup and a half. I took him to the vet today for a broken tooth and the vet asked about what he was eating. I explained everything to him and he told me I was under feeding him and not to feed him less than 2 and a half cups a day. I guess I will just have to keep scooping a lot of food but I feel like he is crapping away my money.