Exclusive has corn and corn gluten, which shouldn't be a problem unless one of your dogs is allergic/sensitive, but it is a potential issue to look out for. Otherwise they both mostly look pretty good (depending on the formula), and are worth a try. It's always nice to be able to buy it locally.
Ok I called Blackwoods and spoke to them. I love the customer service I must say. They are not a company in SC they actually are in Ohio and they only produce Blackwoods products. The type I wanted was grain,soy free and so the lady called my local retailer to see if they had it and if not would they be willing to order it for me. I think I will be going today to get a bag to try.