not to over step my bounderies here, nor do i mean to disrepect anyone....
but, OP was asking for what breed she/he has, NOT that her dogs ar overweight.. remember to you they may look over weight, but, there could be other things that are underlying, ( IE health problems etc), and so, we should not judge by what few pics we see.
i have always been one to free feed my dogs, always have always will, but, i never over step my boundries and tell someone because of what my vet says should go for all dogs, is just not nice

we all love our dogs and we want the best for them, but, we should also consider the posters feelings about things, you, nor i, know what all is going on..
IMHO we should only help guide people with what the posts says, i have joined many forums and find this happens to all. remember to each his/her own, and the only one that knows what really goes on is the owner.
again, i am not trying to be rude or anything, it is just i found that statement to be very, well, crossing the line when you start to say your dog is fat! kinda of thing.
OP your dogs are beatiful and i love the colors, as for the one wether it is GSD or mix, IMPO she does look like she is mixed with maybe lab.. i have a lab/whippet mix with TONS of stuff, to me it does not matter, i love them just the same, the only true way to tell is to get a DNA test, depending on the area it could cost a few dollars to a few 100, but, go check it out, good luck, either way she is cute
