She mostly doesn't get treats in the crate. I think twice she grabbed a toy, but only when it was at the very front of the crate, and she doesn't always do it. Even if I feed her I have to put her bowl on the very edge; she won't even go in for that if she's hungry.
I think if someone were to offer me a locked room with lots of entertainment, I would be pretty happy for a few hours. I only put her in there when she is so tired she's about to fall asleep, it seems a bit unfair to say I'm imprisoning her. Does that mean we imprison babies when we put them in their crib for a nap?
The other thing is that with this gradual process of crate training: where do I put her when I have to leave the house? Or when I'm asleep and can't supervise her? I feel like those who espouse the process you describe don't really answer these questions.
Sorry if I seem defensive, but I really want to be a good dog owner and do the best I can for her. But I also can't realistically watch her 24 hours a day and want to make sure she is rested. I will keep working on this process, like feeding her in the crate, but in the meantime I will have to put her in myself.
Fortunately she has gotten much better in the last few days as I've been working on an exercise/ potty schedule. She only whimpers for maybe a minute or less when I put her in the crate now. I know whenever she lies down under my chair or the sofa that she is tired, so that's when I put her in her crate.
I think if someone were to offer me a locked room with lots of entertainment, I would be pretty happy for a few hours. I only put her in there when she is so tired she's about to fall asleep, it seems a bit unfair to say I'm imprisoning her. Does that mean we imprison babies when we put them in their crib for a nap?
The other thing is that with this gradual process of crate training: where do I put her when I have to leave the house? Or when I'm asleep and can't supervise her? I feel like those who espouse the process you describe don't really answer these questions.
Sorry if I seem defensive, but I really want to be a good dog owner and do the best I can for her. But I also can't realistically watch her 24 hours a day and want to make sure she is rested. I will keep working on this process, like feeding her in the crate, but in the meantime I will have to put her in myself.
Fortunately she has gotten much better in the last few days as I've been working on an exercise/ potty schedule. She only whimpers for maybe a minute or less when I put her in the crate now. I know whenever she lies down under my chair or the sofa that she is tired, so that's when I put her in her crate.