Puppy Forum and Dog Forums banner

Choosing the right breed...

628 Views 5 Replies 6 Participants Last post by  parus
Hi everyone,

My 6 year old son has been asking for a dog of his own, and I'm having some difficulty coming up with a suitable breed.

I live in a single family home with a decently sized, fenced back yard, with 6 foot tall wooden fences.

The biggest obstacle I face are the two dogs that live with us right now: my wife's 9 year old male Chihuahua, who weighs about 12 pounds -and is pretty easy going as far as Chihuahua's go- and a 7 year old male Lab/Terrier mix that was my mom's, he weighs about 22 pounds, and is a docile, sweet pup.

I'd like the new dog to meet the following criteria:

-pure breed, open to a mixed or cross breed
-medium to large in size
-good with children
-good jogging companion (for me)
-halfway decent guard dog
-low wanderlust, if at all possible
-young or young adult (so I can jog with him/her right away), but open to a puppy
-most importantly, one that won't kill both of the other dogs

I had my heart set on an Akita, a Rhodesian Ridgeback or a Black Mouth Cur (or all three!), my son loved those breeds as well, but they don't seem like good choices if I am to keep the Chihuahua alive. I've read that Chihuahas don't fare well with Hounds, large Terriers or Spitz-type dogs.

I also have two parrots, which I imagine would rule out most of the sporting group breeds as well?

So, indeed, this seems to be a tall order. Any guidance would be most appreciated.

My thanks in advance
See less See more
1 - 1 of 6 Posts
Some of your criteria are a little contradictory, I think.

I'd like the new dog to meet the following criteria:
-pure breed, open to a mixed or cross breed
-medium to large in size
-good with children
-good jogging companion (for me)
-halfway decent guard dog
-low wanderlust, if at all possible
-young or young adult (so I can jog with him/her right away), but open to a puppy
-most importantly, one that won't kill both of the other dogs
The "guard dog" bit often doesn't play very nicely with the "good with children and tiny dogs" bit. Yes, there are exceptions, but generally speaking, with small children and small dogs, I don't think you want a dog that has a tendency to solve problems with its teeth. Even if the dog is loyal to and nice with its household, if the dog is going to be your kid's dog, a six year old is too young to control a potentially aggressive dog, I think. You want your kid to be able to safely have friends over.

If you want a dog that's the most sure to be sweet with your kid, not one to eat birds, and tolerant of your other dogs, your best bet is to look for an adult rescue or retired working/show dog and test him/her out with your pets and family. Dogs often have significant temperament changes between puppyhood and age 2, so a pup or adolescent that's nice with your little dogs and uninterested in your parrots can possibly become predatory, aggressive or intolerant as it grows up, especially if it's from a breed known for sharpness, dog aggression, or prey drive.

If you get an adult dog with a clearly demonstrated agreeable temperament, specific breed isn't as important. "Lab mixes" are ubiquitous in rescue and I bet there's a bunch out there that'd make your kid really happy and would be fine with other animals.

If you get a pup, you can hedge your bets by getting one where the breeder focuses on good temperament and good health, including all the OFA-recommended screenings (a dog that's ill, has impaired senses, or has orthopedic pain can be a snappish dog).

Golden Retrievers and Labs are stereotypical family dogs for good reason. (If you're looking at Golden puppies, make sure you go to a breeder that's working for more longevity and lower incidence of cancer in their breed.) You might also think about a corgi or well-bred collie - they're pretty amiable, but being herding dogs, they're more vigilant and more likely to alert bark, which might appeal to that protective aspect you're looking for. (I feel like if you look for a farm dog type collie and not a show dog type collie, you're more likely to end up with one that's stable, has a brain, and is good with other animals - my parents' collie is from working farm dogs and is safe with chickens, for what it's worth.) Jack Russell terriers are smaller than what you're looking for, but they're sturdy, fun dogs that I can easily see as a companion to a young boy, and they'd be closer in size to your other dogs and therefore less likely to accidentally injure them. Terrier instincts might be a problem with the parrots, though, depending on your setup.
See less See more
1 - 1 of 6 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top