So like many others that fed TOTW I wanted to switch. I picked Blackwoods brand in the Salmon potato formula.http://www.blackwoodpetfood.com/fish-and-potato-dog-food so far I like it,the price isn't bad either. To me it isn't super fishy. Im mixing 1/2 and half because my dogs have rock guts. They also have some other types including some allergy and senseative stomach formulas.