As of right now, none of my toys are accessible, because (long story short) we haven't gotten our house yet, so all my stuff is still in storage. We have 5 dogs, each one has a toy in their crate, and there are usually 3 toys out in the living room for them to play with. Any less then that and the fight over the toy too much. My collection is pretty huge... Last time I had them displayed on a twin sized bed, and they covered the bed about 3 feet deep... I think I'll try the whole "if I give it to you, you can have it, if I don't give it to you, it's mine" thing. If not, do you think that they could learn "Toys in this room are yours, toys in that room are mine"?
This may sound sad, since I'm 21 and married, but the main stufties I'm worried about are the ones my husband and I sleep with. Since the dogs started sleeping in bed with my us, we've put our two "bed-buddies" up on a shelf. I'd love to be able to bring them down where they belong, but I'd hate to loose them. (One I've had since I was 13, the other was a gift I got for my hubby when we were dating.) So I think I'll start bringing in non-sentimental stuffed animals, and see how they do with them...