IMO keeping a dog to a certain area while not at home or sleeping is a good thing. whether it's a basement or a crate or a bathroom. Whatever. I think the consistancy helps them learn, "Okay, Mom is gone. SHe's not going to be back for awhile I best settle in." Now, if it's just evening time and you are haning out watching tv or whatever then I would think you would want your dog out with you to spend time with it.
